Table of Contents
The rapid growth of short-term rental accommodation is reshaping Australia’s tourism industry and sparking debate about the future of local housing markets and regional economies. Platforms such as Airbnb have become a major part of the tourism sector, allowing homeowners to rent out spare rooms, holiday houses and investment properties to visitors.
Supporters say short-term rentals help spread tourism income more widely through communities, while critics argue they can place pressure on housing supply in popular destinations. The debate is increasingly relevant for regional areas that rely on tourism, including destinations close to Sydney such as the Hawkesbury.
A Changing Tourism Economy
Short-term rental platforms have grown rapidly over the past decade, offering travellers alternatives to traditional hotels. Advocates say the model allows visitors to stay in neighbourhoods that may not have conventional accommodation, helping tourism dollars flow into smaller communities.
A local short-term rental accommodation host said, “All you need to do is look at the Visitor Spend in the Hawkesbury City Council's monthly newsletter to see how important visitor spend is to our local economy in the Hawkesbury. Yes, in some areas in Australia, I do agree, there are issues regarding over saturation of short term rental accommodation (STRA). However, it is important to note that this does not apply to the Hawkesbury, which heavily relies on short term rental accommodation as a vital part of the local tourism ecosystem.
Hosts can also earn additional income by renting out their homes or investment properties, creating new economic opportunities for residents. Industry groups argue this can help build a more distributed tourism economy where visitors explore a broader range of regional destinations rather than concentrating only in major cities.
Housing Concerns
At the same time, housing advocates warn that the rapid expansion of short-term rentals may reduce the supply of long-term rental properties in some areas. When properties shift from residential housing to holiday accommodation, fewer homes may be available for local residents. This has become a major policy issue in several Australian cities and tourist regions, where local governments have considered regulations aimed at balancing tourism benefits with housing needs.
The local host added, “Did you know that short term rental accommodation only accounts for approximately 1% of total housing stock across Australia? There is no evidence to show that levies or night caps work and in fact, evidence is now appearing that these measures are having a negative impact on local tourism."
The local host also explained the levy in Victoria has been disastrous for regional tourism and local communities. Airdna reports only approximately 113 active listings in the Hawkesbury. Short term rental accommodation is low lying fruit, easy to blame by politicians, however, we are not the cause of the housing crisis and I believe everyone is starting to realise this.
The Local Impact
For areas like the Hawkesbury, tourism plays an important role in the local economy. Visitors are drawn to the region’s natural landscapes, heritage towns and outdoor activities, with nearby destinations such as Blue Mountains National Park attracting travellers from across Australia and overseas. Short-term rentals can provide additional accommodation options for tourists exploring the region.
The host explained, “We also need to remember that the Hawkesbury has limited accommodation offerings, we don't see numerous international hotel chains and family friendly motels, so short term rental accommodation is filling the necessary demand gap. People also forget about other positive impacts short term rental accommodation has. For example, we support local charities, are involved with numerous community initiatives and events, we supply accommodation to emergency personnel and displaced households during disastrous events such as floods, some provide accessible and inclusive accommodation, sustainable & eco-friendly stays too.”
However, as housing affordability becomes a growing issue across outer-metropolitan areas of Sydney, the balance between tourism accommodation and residential housing is becoming an increasingly important conversation for local communities.
Finding the Right Balance
Across Australia, policymakers are continuing to examine how best to regulate the short-term rental sector. Some regions have introduced limits on the number of days properties can be rented each year, while others have implemented registration systems or local planning controls. The goal is often to maintain tourism benefits while ensuring communities retain sufficient housing for permanent residents.
The local host emphasised, “Our hospitality sector, as we all know, has suffered terribly over the past few years. Further restricting short term rental accommodation in the Hawkesbury area will only have a further negative flow on effect to our local hospitality sector. You also have to realise, that the majority of our local short-term accommodation owners and operators are Mums and Dads, who run these rentals to supplement their income particularly due to rising costs of living. The properties themselves might be unsuitable for long term lease. Further to this, many would rather remove their listing altogether and keep it empty than have long term tenants. No one wins in that situation. It's a no brainer and a no win for the Hawkesbury if levies or further night caps are placed on the Hawkesbury’s short term rental accommodation sector.”
As tourism continues to evolve, short-term rental platforms are likely to remain a significant part of the discussion about how regional economies grow and how communities manage the pressures of changing housing markets.
Acknowledgement - Melbourne Age & Airbnb
