Hawkesbury residents deserve transparency from their elected representatives. But what happens when councillors demand accountability from the media while appearing less comfortable with scrutiny directed at themselves? And what does it say about our community when one of our local radio stations may be forced to close?
These questions arise following recent Facebook posts by Greens Councillor Danielle Wheeler, who has taken aim at the Hawkesbury Gazette over its article Hawkesbury people want to be heard, published on 15 November.
Wheeler opened her response with:
"Yet another article full of misinformation from the Hawkesbury Gazette. Here are the facts."
Strong words from an elected representative. But where does legitimate correction end and political criticism of the media begin?
The Gazette and its editor
Wheeler's public criticism of the Gazette has brought its reporting and editorial direction into question.
The newspaper's editor, Kooryn Sheaves, oversees a publication that is clearly prepared to scrutinise local political representatives.
Wheeler's response demonstrates a substantial disagreement with the Gazette's reporting, although the supplied Facebook posts do not establish a personal dispute between Wheeler and Sheaves.
There is nothing wrong with a councillor challenging a newspaper.
Journalists should be questioned. Mistakes should be corrected. Newspapers should be accountable.
But shouldn't exactly the same standards apply to councillors?
A healthy democracy requires independent reporting, even when that reporting makes elected representatives uncomfortable.
The Greens convenor controversy
One of Wheeler's objections concerns the suggestion that she remains the convenor of the Hawkesbury Greens.
Wheeler states she stepped down before her election in 2016 and has not held an office-bearing position since.
Hawkesbury Council's website lists "Convenor, Hawkesbury Greens" under her Previous Community Service, supporting that explanation.
If the Gazette described her as the current convenor, that would warrant correction.
However, broader questions about membership and internal party democracy remain legitimate.
Wheeler says membership applications are decided collectively, with refusals being rare. She also acknowledges that applications can be rejected.
Political organisations are entitled to determine their membership. But transparency around those decisions is an entirely reasonable subject for public discussion.
Political chat pages and anonymous commentary
Another issue worth examining is the role of the Hawkesbury Macquarie Political Chat Facebook page.
Some people who appear supportive of Wheeler's political positions also appear to participate in or support that online environment.
Political discussion is healthy. Personal attacks against ordinary residents are another matter.
The ability to participate anonymously online raises questions about accountability, particularly when elected representatives or their associates are involved in political discussions.
There is no evidence in the supplied material establishing that Wheeler or another councillor has anonymously targeted community members. Nor does support for a Facebook page establish wrongdoing.
Nevertheless, the principle is important.
If councillors expect journalists to identify themselves and stand behind their reporting, should the same expectation apply to elected representatives participating in online political discussions?
Accountability should not depend on political allegiance.
The irony of criticising local media
Perhaps Wheeler's most interesting statement comes towards the end of her Facebook response:
"I welcome legitimate discussion with the community about how and why I do my job, but mis- and disinformation does real harm to democracy."
She also raises concerns about the decline of the media and its effect on people, particularly women, considering public office.
Harassment and intimidation in politics are serious concerns.
But legitimate scrutiny is not automatically misinformation simply because someone disagrees with it.
Equally, a newspaper must correct genuine inaccuracies when they are identified.
The important distinction is between challenging an argument and attempting to discredit the person or organisation presenting it.
Hawkesbury Radio: Another community voice at risk
While Wheeler expresses concern about the decline of the media, another local media organisation faces a very uncertain future.
Hawkesbury Radio Online may cease operating in January 2027.
The community station faces the prospect of losing its long-standing premises at the heritage-listed Fitzgerald Street site in Windsor, owned by Sydney Water.
Members have expressed their desire to remain while preparing for a possible relocation.
However, limited finances and the considerable costs of establishing another studio place the station's future in doubt.
For years, Hawkesbury Radio has provided opportunities for residents, volunteers, businesses, community organisations and elected representatives to be heard.
That includes Councillor Wheeler herself.
In February 2026, Wheeler joined me on The Common Point for an extensive discussion about housing affordability, council finances, childcare, environmental protection and the future of the Hawkesbury.
The interview gave her the opportunity to explain her political positions directly to the community, without the constraints of a short newspaper article.
It demonstrated the importance of independent community broadcasting.
Wheeler is not responsible for Hawkesbury Radio's predicament. The immediate difficulties concern its premises, finances and relationship with Sydney Water.
But the situation raises a broader question.
If we are genuinely concerned about the decline of local media, what practical steps are being taken to protect the organisations that provide it?
Council, local politicians and community organisations have an opportunity to work together before January arrives.
The potential loss of Hawkesbury Radio should concern everyone who values independent local discussion.
From the radio studio to Facebook
What makes this situation particularly interesting is my own experience interviewing Wheeler.
During our February conversation, I acknowledged the considerable work she puts into reading council documents and preparing for meetings.
That observation was genuine, and I stand by it.
Wheeler spoke about protecting agricultural land, improving accountability and ensuring public consultation influences council decisions.
On rate increases, she acknowledged residents' concerns about insufficient information and explained how public feedback influenced the final decision.
It was a respectful and productive conversation.
That is what local media should encourage.
Two people do not need to agree politically to have a worthwhile discussion.
And that is precisely why independent reporting matters.
Accountability cannot be selective
The Hawkesbury Gazette is not the public relations department of Hawkesbury Council, the Greens, Liberals, Labor or any other political organisation.
Its responsibility is to its readers.
That includes asking difficult questions, examining political claims and providing opportunities for response.
It also means correcting mistakes.
Wheeler is entitled to challenge the Gazette. Kooryn Sheaves and the Gazette are equally entitled to scrutinize Wheeler's public statements and political record.
Neither should be immune from criticism.
The question of hypocrisy arises when different standards appear to be applied depending on who is asking the questions.
If a councillor makes an inaccurate statement, it should be corrected.
If a newspaper makes an inaccurate statement, it should be corrected.
And if anyone uses anonymous platforms to intimidate community members, that behaviour should be challenged regardless of political affiliation.
The Common Point
The Hawkesbury is a relatively small community.
Our councillors, journalists, volunteers and residents regularly encounter one another at council meetings, community events and local functions.
We will not always agree, nor should we be expected to.
Wheeler finished her Facebook statement by declaring that Hawkesbury residents deserve the truth and that anything less amounts to disrespect.
On that principle, I agree.
But accountability must work both ways.
And while politicians and newspapers debate who is right, Hawkesbury Radio faces the possibility of falling silent in January.
Perhaps that should remind us all of something important.
Independent local media is not always comfortable, convenient or complimentary.
But once those community voices disappear, getting them back may prove far more difficult than resolving today's political disagreements.
Listen here To the interview with Councillior Danielle Wheeler
Sparky Sean | The Common Point
Local stories. Community voices. Independent conversations.