Table of Contents
During a vigorous discussion at a Gazette Editorial team meeting, I found myself making this statement "You are not entitled to your opinion!". This argument was first put forward by Patrick Stokes (2012) in Australian The Philosopher’s Magazine.
Stokes challenges the common phrase “everyone is entitled to their opinion.” that while people certainly have the legal right to hold opinions, in rational discussion and debate you are not automatically entitled to have your opinion treated as equally valid unless you can back it up with reasons and evidence.
People often invoke “I’m entitled to my opinion” to shut down criticism, as though stating something is enough but this undermines serious discussion. In serious discussion where we expect others to listen, respect, or act on what we say, then we have a responsibility to back it up our opinion with reasons and evidence.
Stokes’ point wasn’t to silence people but to remind us that opinions have consequences. In matters that affect our neighbours, communities, and shared future, tossing opinions around without support isn’t just unhelpful — it can be irresponsible.
The next time someone — or even you — reaches for “I’m entitled to my opinion,” remember Stokes’ challenge. The right to speak is just the start. The real value of an opinion lies in the reasons and evidence behind it.
Tips for Building a Strong Opinion
Having an opinion that stands up in discussion takes effort. Here are a few simple ways to make sure your opinion carries weight:
1. Check the facts
Base your view on reliable sources, not just headlines or hearsay.
2. Ask yourself “why?”
If someone challenges you, can you explain why you hold that opinion?
3. Listen to expertise
Recognise when specialists know more — science, history, law, and local knowledge matter.
4. Be open to change
A strong opinion isn’t fixed forever. New evidence can (and should) shift your perspective.
5. Respect the stakes
If your opinion could affect others’ lives, businesses, or community wellbeing, take extra care to support it.
💡 The bottom line: An opinion with reasons behind it is not just yours — it’s worth sharing.
