On 10 June 2025, Hawkesbury City councillors voted 11–1 to give landowners more flexibility to build two homes on the same lot.
Councillor Nathan Zamprogno moved the motion, Councillor Creed seconded it and Councillor Kotlash cast the only vote against. The instruction was simple. In every zone where attached dual occupancies were permitted, Council would seek to delete the word “Attached” from its Local Environmental Plan. Owners could then seek approval for two separate homes where the rules already allowed two joined homes.
The proposal returned to the chamber on 12 August 2025. This time all 12 councillors, including Kotlash, voted to support it and send it to the NSW planning department. The proposal they endorsed covered six rural, village and conservation zones.
The version residents saw more than a year later still covered those six zones, but it also contained a new draft planning clause that would dictate how close the homes could be, how they could be accessed and where flood levels could rule them out. The Gazette could find no published Council resolution endorsing those later changes before they went on exhibition.
"This is the senior staff doing what they think is best instead of following the Council Chambers instructions." says Cr Dogramaci.
How the proposal changed after the vote
The November 2025 Gateway determination, the State’s conditional permission to proceed with dual occupancy named four zones: Primary Production, Rural Landscape, Primary Production Small Lots and Village.
It left out the two conservation zones from the Council's August 2025 proposal and required further work on flooding.
The State’s September 2026 alteration expressly included Environmental Management and Environmental Living zoning and moved the deadline for completing the Dual Occupancy amendment from 25 August 2026 to 19 March 2027 at Council's request. By the time the public saw the proposal Council had taken so long to process it, that original deadline for completion had already passed.
The Council put the proposal on exhibition ran from 30 September to 29 October. Council said the proposal would provide another housing option for rural families and farm workers.
"That remains a worthwhile aim. A separate home could give an older parent independence or let a farm worker live on the property. What matters is whether those households can actually use the option. That question turns on the new draft clause, which was absent from the proposal councillors endorsed." says Troy Myers Urban City Consulting Windsor. Myers gave evidence to the NSW Legislative Council Inquiry into Rural Housing and Second Dwellings Reform.
Which properties could use it?
Under draft clause 6.18, a second dwelling would have to sit within 50 metres of the principal dwelling, and both would have to share a single driveway access point onto the public road. A landowner might have a suitable building site elsewhere on the same lot and still be unable to use it. On an unsewered property, there would also have to be enough suitable land to manage wastewater on site. The consent authority would need to consider whether the development would hinder agriculture or rural industries on the property or adjoining land.
None of these conditions were put to Councillors or debated before the Chamber before being placed in the document that went on public exhibition.
Further any proposed dual occupancy secondary dwelling site would have to sit above the adopted flood planning level. For flood-prone land above that level and below the probable maximum flood planning level, each home would have to be under 185 square metres and the two homes could have no more than eight bedrooms between them. The draft also caps development at two dwellings on the lot and would allow subdivision of a dual occupancy only if the resulting lots meet the mapped minimum lot size. Again none of these conditions were put to Councillors or debated before being placed in the document.
Flooding is a real constraint in the Hawkesbury. The NSW State Emergency Service raised concerns about evacuation, isolation and the added complexity of responding to floods. Council’s exhibition report argues that tighter controls would contain those risks.
There is a public case for restrictions where the evidence supports them. There is also a public case for showing councillors and residents how those restrictions work together. A property might have higher ground but no suitable site within 50 metres of the existing home. A site within 50 metres might have inadequate space for wastewater disposal. The number of zones in the amendment tells residents very little about how many lots could pass those tests.
There is a practical difference between showing that a lot is in one of the six zones and showing that it has a usable building site. For families weighing up whether to stay on a property together, that difference matters. A zoning map can answer the first question. The second takes a look at the house, the road, the terrain and the space available for both homes inviting many more decision to be made by Council.
The next decision belongs in public
As at 15 November, the NSW Planning Portal still listed the proposal at Gateway Implementation. The exhibition had closed, and the Gazette could find no published post-exhibition Council decision or final amendment.
OPINION: What can Councillors do?
When the submissions are reported, councillors could be given a side-by-side comparison of the proposal they endorsed and the version now before them. The report could say which changes the State required, which Council staff proposed in response, and what evidence supports the 50-metre limit and shared access rule.
It should also show, as far as Council’s mapping allows, where the flood controls would rule out otherwise eligible building sites and how many lots are likely to remain viable. Where Council cannot estimate that, it should explain what information is missing.
The public vote was about giving landowners a choice. The exhibition draft gave that choice a much narrower set of conditions, with no fresh public vote on those conditions that the Gazette could find.
"The next time councillors consider the proposal, they should be able to tell a family in the Colo, on a farm or in one of the Hawkesbury’s villages whether the change is likely to give them a real option for a second home." says Myers.